Every business is different, and so are its accounting needs. A five-person service company, a growing e-commerce brand, and a contractor juggling 1099 workers will each need a different kind of accountant. Hiring the wrong fit costs more than a salary. It shows up as late filings, missed deductions, and IRS penalties.
This guide shows you how to hire an accountant who matches your business. It is based on what our in-house tax and bookkeeping team sees when new clients move their books to ProfitsView.
Key takeaways
- Define your needs before you hire. Your industry, monthly transaction volume, and budget decide what kind of accountant you need.
- Match skills to those needs. Check four areas: core accounting, communication, time management, and the specific software you use.
- Write a precise job post. List the skills, software, and responsibilities so only qualified candidates apply.
- Compare in-house and outsourced options. 23% of US accountants already work for accounting, tax, and bookkeeping service firms. Outsourcing gives small businesses the same expertise without a full-time hire.
- Hiring the wrong fit is risky. Late filings and messy books lead to IRS penalties. Accurate books and on-time filings protect your business.
What we see when new clients hand us their books
Since 2012, ProfitsView has onboarded small businesses and entrepreneurs who are switching from DIY bookkeeping, a part-time bookkeeper, or an accountant who wasn’t the right fit. On the first review of a new client’s books, we keep finding the same problems:
- Bank and credit card accounts that haven’t been reconciled for months. The balance in the software no longer matches the bank.
- Personal and business expenses mixed together. This makes deductions hard to support if the IRS asks.
- Missed or underpaid quarterly estimated taxes. These usually come to light only at year-end, when penalties have already built up.
- Payroll, 1099, and sales tax filings done late or not at all. This happens most often in the first two years of a business.
In our experience, the businesses that struggled most didn’t lack an accountant. They had hired one whose skills didn’t match their industry or their volume of transactions. The steps below are meant to prevent exactly that mismatch.
Why is hiring an accountant essential?
An accountant is the financial backbone of a business. For a new company, a good accountant keeps cash flowing in the right direction while you focus on growth. A good accountant will:
- Keep your books current and accurate, and protect the security of your financial data.
- Keep you compliant with local, state, and federal tax rules and filing deadlines.
- Turn numbers into decisions by comparing options and recommending the financial actions that fit your goals.
- Help you choose the right accounting method and business structure (for example, LLC vs. S-Corp election) for your situation.
- Support internal projects such as budgeting, pricing, and financing with clear financial analysis.
- Track industry standards and trends that affect your margins and tax position.
Accounting jobs in the US: key numbers
| Data point | Figure | Source |
|---|---|---|
| Accountant & auditor jobs in the US | ~1.6 million (2024) | U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics |
| Projected job growth, 2024–2034 | 5% (faster than average) | U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics |
| New accountant & auditor jobs expected, 2024–2034 | 72,800 | U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics |
| Share employed by accounting, tax prep, bookkeeping & payroll firms | 23% | U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics |
| Employer share of FICA on a salaried hire | 7.65% of wages | IRS Topic No. 751 |
Here is what that means in practice. Demand for accountants keeps growing, so experienced hires are competitive. A full-time hire also adds employer payroll taxes of 7.65% on top of salary, plus benefits. Nearly a quarter of US accountants already work for service firms, which is why outsourced or part-time support is the practical choice for most small businesses.
How to hire the right accountant in 3 steps
Break the hiring process into three parts. Start by defining what your business needs, then identify the skills that meet those needs, and finish with a job post that attracts only qualified candidates.
Step 1: Define your business requirements
Before you look at a single resume, be clear about what you actually need. Work through these four questions:
What industry knowledge is required?
Every industry has its own rules. Construction uses job costing and retainage, e-commerce deals with multi-state sales tax, and healthcare has strict compliance requirements. If you regularly run into industry-specific regulations, hire an accountant with direct experience in your sector.
How much accounting work do you have?
Count your monthly transactions, bank and card accounts, payroll runs, and filing obligations. A business with 50 transactions a month needs a very different setup from one with 2,000. If records are already piling up or going unreconciled, treat it as urgent. Messy books get more expensive to fix every month.
What is your budget?
Ask yourself how much you can invest in finance support and what it costs you to keep doing it yourself. For many small businesses, a part-time or outsourced accountant delivers the same quality as a full-time hire at a fraction of the cost. A full-time salary only makes sense once your workload truly fills one.
Should you outsource or hire in-house?
If your budget is tight, outsourcing is usually the best value. A professional accounting service can handle your bookkeeping, tax, and reporting for a monthly fee or a project-based price that scales with your needs. An annual invoice can look large on paper, but you get a team of specialists for less than one in-house hire.
Case study: an e-commerce LLC choosing outsourced over in-house
Situation: A small e-commerce LLC came to us while weighing a full-time in-house accountant against an outsourced team. Sales came in through Shopify and Stripe and landed in two bank accounts. The books were several months behind, and the owner was doing reconciliations at night.
What we did: We moved the books to QuickBooks Online and cleared the backlog by reconciling every account. Then we set up a fixed monthly close and a review of estimated taxes every quarter.
Result:
- Cost: The owner skipped a full-time hire, along with the 7.65% employer payroll tax and benefits that come with one, and paid only for the hours the business actually needed.
- Speed: Monthly reports now arrive on a fixed schedule each month, instead of whenever the owner found the time.
- Compliance: Our first quarterly review caught an underpaid estimated tax payment, which was corrected before year-end penalties grew.
Client name withheld for confidentiality.
Step 2: Identify the skill set you need
Once you know your requirements, match them to specific skills. These are the four areas to assess:
Core accounting skills
Every accountant you consider should be strong in:
- Bookkeeping and account reconciliation
- Budgeting and forecasting
- Preparing financial statements (P&L, balance sheet, cash flow)
- Data analysis
- Business taxation and filing deadlines
Communication skills
Accounting touches every part of a business. Your accountant will deal with sales, operations, payroll, and sometimes your customers or lenders. To test communication:
- Rate how clearly they explain financial concepts to you during the interview.
- Give them a real scenario, such as a client disputing an invoice, and see how they would handle it.
- Confirm whether they are available for in-person meetings if you need them.
- Ask how they prefer to communicate (phone, email, or video) and how quickly they typically respond.
Adaptability and time management
Strong accountants plan their work around deadlines: month-end close, quarterly estimates, and year-end filings. Ask how they organize a busy tax season. Adaptability matters just as much. Tax rules and accounting software change every year, so look for someone who stays current without being pushed.
Technical skills
Decide which tools your accountant must already know. Common requirements include:
- Spreadsheets: Excel or Google Sheets (pivot tables, lookups)
- Bookkeeping software: QuickBooks, Xero, or Zoho Books
- Payroll platforms: Gusto, ADP, or similar
- Reporting: PowerPoint or dashboard tools for presenting results
Set a minimum number of years of hands-on experience with your core software. This one filter will shorten your shortlist quickly.
Step 3: Post the right job advertisement
A precise job post saves time on both sides. Include:
- The specific skills and software from Step 2
- Clear responsibilities, such as monthly close, payroll, sales tax, and year-end filing support
- Industry experience you require
- Whether the role is full-time, part-time, or contract, and whether it is remote or on-site
Hiring doesn’t end with the offer letter. Give your new accountant a proper onboarding: access to systems, a walkthrough of past filings, and an introduction to your team. Then set clear performance expectations, such as close deadlines, reporting cadence, and accuracy standards, so they know how success will be measured.
In a nutshell: choosing the right accountant
The right accountant depends on your industry, your transaction volume, and your budget. Define your needs first, match them to specific skills, and write a job post that filters for those skills. For most small businesses, the numbers point toward outsourced or part-time support until the workload justifies a full-time hire.
If you would rather have your books handled by an experienced accounting professional without the cost of a full-time hire, the ProfitsView team can help. We have supported small businesses and entrepreneurs since 2012. Start a free trial or talk to our team.
Sources
- U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics – Occupational Outlook Handbook: Accountants and Auditors
- IRS Topic No. 751 – Social Security and Medicare Withholding Rates
- ProfitsView client onboarding reviews, 2012–2026