Payroll is one of the first services a new small business needs. It is also one of the easiest to get wrong. What you pay depends on two things. The first is the software you use. The second is whether you outsource payroll or run it in-house.

A payroll provider usually handles eight tasks for you:

  1. Payroll and income tax calculations
  2. State and local tax filings
  3. Tracking hours worked
  4. IRS tax deposits
  5. Employer forms and taxes
  6. Paying employees
  7. Overtime calculations
  8. Payroll record keeping

Key takeaways

  • Most providers charge two fees. You pay a monthly base fee plus a fee for each employee.
  • Pay frequency changes the bill. Weekly payroll costs more than biweekly or monthly payroll.
  • Extras add up. Direct deposit, time tracking, and multi-state taxes can raise your monthly cost.
  • You have four main options. These are outsourced bookkeeping, payroll software, an in-house bookkeeper, or an online payroll provider.
  • Outsourcing is usually cheaper for small teams. You pay only for the work done, with no salary or benefits to cover.

What we see when we take over a client’s payroll

When a small business moves its payroll to ProfitsView, we review its last 12 months of payroll first. In our experience, the same problems show up again and again:

  • Paying more often than needed. Many teams run weekly payroll out of habit. Moving to biweekly cuts the number of pay runs from 52 to 26 a year. That halves the per-run processing fees.
  • Paying for unused features. Many owners are on full-service plans but use only basic pay runs and tax filing.
  • Manual timesheets. Paper or spreadsheet timesheets cause most of the overtime and pay errors we correct.
  • Missed state registrations. Remote hires in a new state often trigger a tax registration the owner didn’t know about.

What we’ve learned is simple. The biggest savings rarely come from switching providers. They come from fixing pay frequency, plan level, and timekeeping first.

What is the average payroll service cost for a small business?

Payroll always costs something, whether you run it yourself or use a provider. With a provider, expect three types of cost:

  • A monthly base fee
  • A fee for each employee
  • Employer-paid payroll taxes

Monthly base fee

Most providers charge a base fee of about $30 to $150 per month. Basic plans sit at the low end. Full-service plans cost more.

Per-employee fee

Providers also charge about $2 to $20 per employee each month. This fee covers deposits, check processing, and tax filings for that person.

Pay frequency

Each pay run has its own processing cost. So the more often you pay, the more you spend. Here is a simple example using a $2 fee per employee for each pay run:

  • Biweekly pay: about $4 per employee per month. That is about $80 a month for 20 employees.
  • Weekly pay: about $8 per employee per month. That is about $160 a month for 20 employees.

Months with an extra pay date will cost a little more.

Direct deposit

Direct deposit is convenient for you and your employees. But some providers charge for setup or for each deposit. Check these fees before you sign up.

Employees in more than one state

Each state has its own payroll tax rules. If your team works in several states, payroll gets harder. Many providers charge more for multi-state filing.

A payroll service makes compliance much easier. Still, some providers cost more than small businesses expect. Many owners also look for cheaper options after QuickBooks price increases. The alternatives below can help.

What are the best payroll alternatives for small businesses?

1. Outsourced bookkeeping

An outsourced bookkeeping service can run payroll along with your books. You hire an outside bookkeeper instead of a payroll-only provider. Their overhead is lower, so you get professional work at a fair price.

2. Payroll automation software

Payroll software makes payroll faster and cheaper. Before you choose a tool, think about three things:

  • How many employees you have
  • What level of service you need
  • How much staff time you can spare

Good software also includes automatic timekeeping. Employees clock in and out online. The system tracks breaks, overtime, vacation, and paid time off in one place. This avoids the errors that come with paper timesheets.

Employees can also update their own tax and payroll details online. Their data stays private. ProfitsView payroll services include these features for hourly teams.

3. In-house bookkeeping

Payroll needs specialist skills. You can have a bookkeeper run it. Or you can hire a full-time finance expert. A full-time in-house hire costs about $70,000 to $75,000 a year. That makes it the most expensive option for most small businesses.

4. Online payroll providers

Online payroll providers handle tax rules, deductions, filings, and payments for you. For many small businesses, this is the cheapest way to stay compliant. It also scales easily as your team grows.

Example from our work: a 20-person restaurant group

This is a representative scenario based on the payroll clients we support. Details are generalized to protect client confidentiality.

Situation: A restaurant group with about 20 hourly staff ran weekly payroll. Managers collected paper timesheets and typed hours into a spreadsheet. Overtime errors meant several paycheck corrections every month.

What we changed:

  • Moved the team from weekly to biweekly pay, so pay runs went from 52 to 26 a year.
  • Replaced paper timesheets with electronic clock-in and clock-out.
  • Switched to a basic payroll plan, because the full-service extras weren’t being used.
  • Combined payroll with the monthly bookkeeping, so wages and taxes matched the books.

What changes: Processing fees drop because there are half as many pay runs. Overtime is calculated automatically, so paycheck corrections become rare. The owner reviews one payroll report every two weeks instead of chasing timesheets every week.

In our experience, a business like this usually sees the difference within the first two pay cycles.

Small business payroll cost FAQs

How much does payroll cost per employee?

Most providers charge a flat fee of about $30 to $150 per month. They add about $2 to $20 for each employee. Your final cost depends on how often you pay and whether you choose basic or full-service payroll.

Is it cheaper to outsource payroll?

Usually, yes. When you outsource, you pay only for the work specialists do for you. You don’t pay a salary, bonuses, or benefits. You can also pick a provider that fits your budget.

What expenses does payroll cover?

Payroll covers salaries, payroll taxes, bonuses, and paid time off. Some providers charge extra for time tracking, paycheck delivery, or 401(k) contributions.